The hill-station desk: Silver thimble, Pencil case & Lunch tin
After the last hill train, the station custodian checked six labelled objects at the lost-property desk. A spill wiped the time column. Iris can still read the marginal notes. Train departure times are not needed to reconstruct the desk log.
Read the clues ↓EXHIBIT REGISTER
Six pieces of evidence
These are labels, not a timeline. Use the clues to reconstruct the only possible order.
- ASilver thimble
- BPencil case
- CLunch tin
- DPocket whistle
- EChess knight
- FFloral scarf
WITNESS NOTES
What the record establishes
- Pocket whistle came before Lunch tin.
- Position 5 held either Floral scarf or Lunch tin.
- Pencil case and Silver thimble were consecutive, in an unknown order.
- Exactly one slip separated Silver thimble and Lunch tin; either could have come first.
- Silver thimble came somewhere between Floral scarf and Chess knight; the ends need not be adjacent to it.
- Silver thimble came somewhere between Pencil case and Chess knight; the ends need not be adjacent to it.
- Floral scarf came before Chess knight.
Open one hint
Draw six slots. Apply clue 1 by itself. Pocket whistle can occupy only these slots: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5.
YOUR WORKING COPY
Build the timeline
Put the earliest exhibit first. Move the exhibits up or down, then check your timeline.
- Silver thimble
- Pencil case
- Lunch tin
- Pocket whistle
- Chess knight
- Floral scarf
Challenge a friend to the same case. Your evidence order and the solution stay private.
Preview or copy the invitation
Can you solve Iris’s case #4040? Six exhibits, one timeline.
https://sival.si/casebook/en/case-4040?via=case-challenge
Open the case solution and reasoning
Resolved timeline
- Floral scarf
- Pencil case
- Silver thimble
- Pocket whistle
- Lunch tin
- Chess knight
Why this order works
Through clue 1: Pocket whistle can occupy only these slots: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5. Orders still possible: 360.
Through clue 2: Pocket whistle can occupy only these slots: 1, 2, 3, 4. Orders still possible: 156.
Through clue 3: Pencil case can occupy only these slots: 1, 2, 3, 4. Orders still possible: 42.
Through clue 4: Silver thimble can occupy only these slots: 2, 3, 4. Orders still possible: 13.
Through clue 5: Lunch tin can occupy only these slots: 5, 6. Orders still possible: 8.
Through clue 6: Silver thimble must occupy position 3. Orders still possible: 3.
Through clue 7: Pocket whistle must occupy position 4. Orders still possible: 1.
AFTER THE PUZZLE
Turn the evidence into a scene
Iris, I am reconstructing the six-slip register at the hill railway station. Here is one note: “Position 5 held either Floral scarf or Lunch tin.” Ask me what it rules out, one question at a time. Do not invent more clues or reveal the solution.
Use this opening in your own story or copy it into a conversation with Iris, SIVAL’s fictional AI detective.
Meet Iris ↗