The hill-station desk: Sketch tube, Lunch tin & Chess knight
After the last hill train, the station custodian checked six labelled objects at the lost-property desk. A spill wiped the time column. Iris can still read the marginal notes. Train departure times are not needed to reconstruct the desk log.
Read the clues ↓EXHIBIT REGISTER
Six pieces of evidence
These are labels, not a timeline. Use the clues to reconstruct the only possible order.
- ASketch tube
- BLunch tin
- CChess knight
- DSilver thimble
- EPaper parasol
- FPencil case
WITNESS NOTES
What the record establishes
- Chess knight and Silver thimble were consecutive, in an unknown order.
- Sketch tube came before Silver thimble.
- Pencil case came somewhere between Sketch tube and Chess knight; the ends need not be adjacent to it.
- Lunch tin and Paper parasol were not consecutive.
- Position 2 held either Lunch tin or Silver thimble.
- Position 6 held either Lunch tin or Silver thimble.
Open one hint
Draw six slots. Apply clue 1 by itself. Cross out joint placements of Chess knight and Silver thimble that violate this clue.
YOUR WORKING COPY
Build the timeline
Put the earliest exhibit first. Move the exhibits up or down, then check your timeline.
- Sketch tube
- Lunch tin
- Chess knight
- Silver thimble
- Paper parasol
- Pencil case
Challenge a friend to the same case. Your evidence order and the solution stay private.
Preview or copy the invitation
Can you solve Iris’s case #4535? Six exhibits, one timeline.
https://sival.si/casebook/en/case-4535?via=case-challenge
Open the case solution and reasoning
Resolved timeline
- Sketch tube
- Lunch tin
- Pencil case
- Paper parasol
- Chess knight
- Silver thimble
Why this order works
Through clue 1: Cross out joint placements of Chess knight and Silver thimble that violate this clue. Orders still possible: 240.
Through clue 2: Sketch tube can occupy only these slots: 1, 2, 3, 4. Orders still possible: 120.
Through clue 3: Pencil case can occupy only these slots: 2, 3, 4. Orders still possible: 40.
Through clue 4: Sketch tube can occupy only these slots: 1, 2. Orders still possible: 24.
Through clue 5: Lunch tin must occupy position 2. Orders still possible: 4.
Through clue 6: Chess knight must occupy position 5. Orders still possible: 1.
AFTER THE PUZZLE
Turn the evidence into a scene
Iris, I am reconstructing the six-slip register at the hill railway station. Here is one note: “Pencil case came somewhere between Sketch tube and Chess knight; the ends need not be adjacent to it.” Ask me what it rules out, one question at a time. Do not invent more clues or reveal the solution.
Use this opening in your own story or copy it into a conversation with Iris, SIVAL’s fictional AI detective.
Meet Iris ↗