SIVAL.si
English ▾

Iris’s casebook

How to write a fair-play mystery clue

A clock in an archive reads 8:10. The detective says a visitor crossed the room after 8:15. Before writing the reveal, decide what the reader could actually prove.

Try the scene with Iris

For adults 18+. Fictional AI characters.

Give the clock a job

Show that the second hand is still. The dial can draw suspicion toward 8:10, but it cannot tell us when anyone entered. Keep that distinction in the detective’s notes.

Plant evidence the reader can inspect

At 8:15 the keeper draws an unbroken chalk line across the only doorway. Later, a shoe has dragged fresh chalk into the room. Let the reader see both details before the detective explains them.

Test the limits of the reveal

We are adult investigators in a fictional archive. The clock is stopped at 8:10. At 8:15 the keeper drew a chalk line. A shoe later dragged chalk inside. Ask what I can prove. Leave the visitor unnamed.
Meet Iris ↗
Your question is not sent automatically.

The shoe crossed after the line was drawn. The mark alone gives neither the visitor’s identity nor the exact minute. If the ending names a suspect, plant a separate clue that distinguishes that person.

Try it step by step

  1. Write the observation and the inference on separate lines.
  2. Remove the chalk mark and reread the ending. If the detective can still assert the time, find where the narrator smuggled it in.

Questions before you start

Can the stopped clock stay in the final draft?

Yes. Give it a visible reason to be unreliable. A reader who notices the still hand can challenge the tempting time before the reveal.

Keep exploring

Try the scene with Iris